Benny's Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Benny's Pizza offers a diverse menu that caters to everyone. Start with appetizers like cheesy mozzarella sticks and crispy garlic knots to kick off your meal. For the main event, savor their traditional pizzas, including the popular cheese pizzas and an array of specialty pies. The menu features beloved classics such as the chicken cheesesteak and the hearty steak sandwiches.

Don't forget to try their signature buffalo wings, served with blue cheese and celery. Plenty of options are available for those craving comfort food, including wraps, burgers, and clubs.

You can bring the kids along too; there's a dedicated children’s menu featuring favorites like chicken fingers and ravioli. Serious eaters with big appetites will appreciate the substantial house special dinners and pasta options, making Benny's a local gem.

Benny's Pizza Menu image 1
Benny's Pizza Menu image 2
Benny's Pizza Menu image 3
Benny's Pizza Menu image 4

Featured Dishes

Meat Lovers Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Sicilian Pizza with Pepperoni and Sausage
Sicilian Pizza with Pepperoni and Sausage
Cheese Steak Sandwich
Cheese Steak Sandwich
Pizza by the Sliced Tomato Sauce
Pizza by the Sliced Tomato Sauce
White Pizza with Garlic
White Pizza with Garlic
Cheese Pizza Steak
Cheese Pizza Steak
Chicken Salad
Chicken Salad
Cheese Steak with Fried Onions and Ketchup
Cheese Steak with Fried Onions and Ketchup
Large Cheese Pizza
Large Cheese Pizza
Triple Cheese Cheesesteak
Triple Cheese Cheesesteak
Half Cheese Half Pepperoni Pizza
Half Cheese Half Pepperoni Pizza
Plain Pizza
Plain Pizza
Hot Buffalo Wings
Hot Buffalo Wings
★Appetizers
★Salads
★Soup
★Wraps
★Buffalo Wings
★Burgers
★Clubs
★Children's Menu
★Cold Italian Subs
★Hot Italian Subs
★Chicken Subs
★House Special Dinner
★Pasta Dinners★- (Choose Spaghetti, Linguini, Ziti, Rigatoni or Fettuccine)
★Traditional Italian Pizza
★Sicilian Square Pizza
★Stromboli, Panzarotti or Calzone
Benny's Pizza

Benny's Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

Benny's Pizza welcomes diners with a cozy, inviting atmosphere. The interior strikes a balance between casual and charming, making it a great spot for families and friends to gather over a delicious meal. Bright colors and local artwork adorn the walls, creating a sense of community.

The open kitchen allows guests to watch the skillful preparation of their favorite dishes. This interactive element enhances the dining experience. With plenty of seating, Benny's Pizza accommodates both small and large groups, ensuring a comfortable space for everyone. The overall ambiance feels lively and warm, perfect for digging into delectable pizzas and hearty sandwiches.

Benny's Pizza

About Benny's Pizza Food and Specialties

Each dish at Benny's Pizza stands out for its quality and flavor. The chefs use fresh ingredients to create mouthwatering meals that locals rave about. Signature items like the panzerottis or pizza steak showcase the unique blend of Italian flavors. The cheesesteaks come with your choice of toppings, allowing for customization that suits every taste. You can also opt for the loaded fries, whether you prefer them plain or topped with cheese.

Benny's prides itself on its variety, featuring a robust selection of salads, wraps, and subs.

For those with a craving for something heartier, the Italian hoagie and the baked pasta dishes are worthy contenders. With 129 menu items overall, Benny's Pizza ensures that everyone finds their favorite dish.

Benny's Pizza

Benny's Pizza is committed to excellence and community engagement. Each recipe reflects a deep respect for Italian culinary traditions, updated with local flavors. Specialties like the panzerotti and garlic knots showcase that commitment to quality and taste. The vision for Benny's extends beyond serving delicious food; it aims to build a community. Benny's welcomes groups from all walks of life, making it a beloved spot for locals.

Through friendly service and a great dining environment, the restaurant fosters connections among its visitors.

Benny’s amplifies its community involvement by participating in local events and supporting nearby schools and charities. This familial approach ensures that everyone feels at home, able to share a meal while connecting over their shared love for great food. Benny’s Pizza is not just a restaurant; it is a vibrant part of the Wenonah story.