Benny's Pizza

Discover Benny's Pizza in Wenonah, NJ, your local gem for delicious cheese steaks, mozzarella sticks, panzerottis, and handcrafted pizzas. Call +1 856-468-0463 for authentic flavors and great food today!

Welcome to Benny's Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Benny's Pizza
Benny's Pizza
Benny's Pizza
Benny's Pizza

Discover Benny's Pizza, a local gem in Wenonah, NJ. Tucked away at 1056 Mantua Pike, this cozy pizza restaurant brings the community together with hearty and delicious offerings. The aroma of fresh pizza wafts through the air as you walk in, setting the scene for a memorable meal. With a wide selection of flavors, Benny’s captures the essence of Italian-American cuisine in every bite. From classic cheese slices to decadent bacon cheesesteaks, the menu satisfies even the most discerning palate. Whether you're dining with friends, family, or enjoying a solo slice, Benny’s Pizza feels just like home.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

1056 Mantua Pike, Wenonah, NJ 08090, United States

Phone

+1 856-468-0463

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Benny's Pizza
Benny's Pizza
Benny's Pizza
Benny's Pizza

Benny's Pizza stands as a pillar of the Wenonah community, serving delicious Italian-inspired cuisine for years. It opened its doors to fulfill the local demand for tasty, high-quality meals. Each dish reflects a commitment to flavor, with a particular emphasis on fresh ingredients. Regulars are particularly fond of signature offerings like the chicken cheesesteak and garlic knots, which pair perfectly with a slice of pizza for a comforting meal.

The diverse menu ensures there’s something for everyone. From hot sandwiches like steak or chicken cheese steaks to cold subs and wraps, Benny's delivers variety. Children happily munch on items from the kids' menu, featuring classics like chicken fingers and spaghetti, making it a family-friendly destination.

Diners can choose from a range of pizza options, including Sicilian square pizza and traditional rounds, loaded with toppings of choice. For those seeking a heartier meal, the house special dinners like baked lasagna or stuffed shells hold high praise. Plus, the restaurant's commitment to affordability ensures everyone can indulge in their favorites without worry.

On busy weekends, Benny's transforms into a lively gathering space. Locals often enjoy dropping in for a quick bite and conversation. The restaurant also sees a surge during lunch hours, particularly on Saturdays, when the hustle and bustle reflect the community's love for its favorite hangout. Benny's Pizza doesn't just offer food; it offers a taste of home.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday12-8 PM
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • TuesdayClosed
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9:30 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Benny's Pizza boasts an extensive menu that caters to everyone. Its biggest draws include mouthwatering cheese steaks, crispy mozzarella sticks, and an iconic pizza steak that locals love. With appetizers, salads, soups, and hearty subs, there's something for every craving. The bustling atmosphere adds to the dining experience, particularly during peak times like Friday evenings.

Benny's provides seating for families or groups, creating a vibrant community hub. With an average meal price of $12.44, it's possible to treat yourself without breaking the bank.

The friendly staff contributes to the welcoming vibe, ensuring each customer receives attention and care. After a long week, Benny's becomes the perfect spot to unwind with a favorite dish.

Benny's Pizza

The exterior of Benny's Pizza draws you in with its warm, inviting signage and a casual yet lively façade. It's the kind of place that feels instantly welcoming. The outdoor seating captures the essence of community dining, allowing patrons to enjoy their meals al fresco during warm months. It’s a favorite spot to gather, as families and friends come together under the sun while enjoying their favorite Italian dishes. The vibe inside mirrors this communal energy, with laughter and conversation filling the air. You’ll often hear the clinking of plates and the sizzling sounds from the kitchen, evoking an atmosphere that feels like a celebration of good food.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

The best Pizza in Oak Valley!!! Great family owned business. Their Penne Vodka is SO good it's addictive!!!! Their mozzarella sticks are homemade. Honestly, I could go on and on. All around the best!

D
Dawn B.

Been a customer 20 years great pizza and sandwiches wonderful staff,I order in the day time there delivery guy is so nice and my food comes quick all the time tony makes the best pizza in south jersey bennys is the place to go i highly recommen got to go to BENNYS

J
Joseph D.

The manager is great. The food is excellent. It's more of a pickup place but they do have a few bar stools. The Kaak was great addition and both chicken and beef are tasty. Next time, regular bread.

F
Food T.

I visited Benny's pizza today and the counter girl, Melanie, did a super amazing job! She was very nice and you can tell they all care about their work. Such a great experience.

A
Ashlynn M.

Great service Benny special cheese steak was large and tasty fries were good and the people were very nice The price was reasonable. Very reasonable for what you get.

J
JB1 T.

The best pizza steak around. Kind and great service. The pizza is great too. Reasonable compared to other places around.

K
Kevin D.